I will keep the insurance /contractor info limited in this post since this is primary a shingle related question. It applies to kitchen and bathroom remodeling, and it applies to roofing. Many CertainTeed products weigh more than 250lbs per square (100 square feet), and the very top lines like Arcadia Shake (450lbs), Grand Manor (425lbs) and Carriage House (355lbs) are extremely robust. GAF vs. CertainTeed shingles cost; Quality level Shingle type Cost per square* Good: GAF Timberline NS: $75: Good: CertainTeed Landmark: $78: Better: GAF Timberline HDZ: $93: Better: CertainTeed Landmark Pro: $120: Best: GAF Timberline UHD: $135: Best: CertainTeed Landmark … This comparison hits all the important factors in deciding – Quality, cost, styles, pros and cons of each option, warranties and more. This article is intended to break down the features of asphalt composition laminated shingles produced by the major brands in the United States. We would recommend that you carefully examine any contracts you have signed with the contractor who initially installed the GAF roof to see what specific items the contractor was directly responsible for, and what was the responsibility of GAF. — This is one of the reasons GAF warranties are not as long or comprehensive as CertainTeed’s (see the details below). I have worked with Certainteed and GAF, both a good quality shingles. GAF became the best-selling shingle brand because it makes good products. In business, it is a thing of integrity when you promise less and do more. GAF and CertainTeed combine for a huge piece of the roofing shingle market. nah,same shit as before,just little bit wider single thick nailing area,double thick is still same 0.5" wide and if you missnail you get crooked in cold, same as certainshit and other brands GAF Timberline are a more economical choice, that have more color options and would work best in milder climates. — CertainTeed wants a bigger cut of the market, so it has reined in prices on its middle-of-the-road products. The Layman's Guide To Choosing An Asphalt Shingle If you are a consumer looking for the best asphalt shingle, then you have come to the right place. They are Class A fire-rated and have similar ASTM (American Society for Testing and Materials) certifications. Cant ever go wrong with Certainteed landmarks. https://www.roofingcalc.com/gaf-vs-certainteed-roofing-shingles However … I plan on staying at this current home for a while to retirement (last house was 12 years). Quality in roofing shingles is determined by how much material is used and how the shingle is constructed. Replacing shingles brings an average cost-to-value return at resale of 66%. More material, as well-constructed as CertainTeed shingles are, leads to better resistance to the wind, impact, cupping, and cracking. Both brands make a large selection, so finding several good-looking options to fit your home’s architecture, style and setting will not be hard. Comparatively, GAF Timberline HD shingles are on … Powered by Discourse, best viewed with JavaScript enabled, New roof: GAF Timberline HDZ vs CertainTeed Landmark Premium. Its between the Certainteed Landmark in Moire Black and the GAF Timberline HD in Charcoal(formerly Timberline Pristique HD). Advantage — CertainTeed: We are arguing very good vs. the best here, not junk vs. quality. Have the roofer check your roof deck and the attic space ventilation. A new roof can help you sell your home, because home buyers cannot afford to, or don’t want the hassle of replacing the roof on a home they just purchased. See individual products for which warranty applies or is optional as an upgrade. *Compare to GAF Timberline and Timberline Ultra, CertainTeed Landmark Premium and Independence, Owens Corning Duration and Duration Designer and Tamko Heritage and Heritage Premium. y2k600f4 September 11, 2020, 6:33pm #1. GAF, the largest manufacturer of residential roofing materials, makes mostly good-quality shingles with a few premium lines like Camelot II Shingles that are exceptional. Talked to a couple companies. Shingle Color Options Due to variation in monitors and printers, the color samples seen on your computer screen may not exactly match the corresponding shingle. Most GAF shingles are cost-conscious products that compete with Owens-Corning, IKO, Tamko, Malarkey and similar brands for “basic and better” ranges — niches it ranks first in. For a $25k+ roof I want to make sure I get top material. They merged with Elk in 2007, but continue to manufacture both Elk and GAF brands. The bottom line on CertainTeed is that you pay more for comparable products to GAF’s, but get better quality. GAF vs. Owens Corning Decision. GAF and CertainTeed have reputation for being among the best and they are commonly compared. malarkey,atlas both have legit 0.8-1" wide double thick which really makes it retardproof. CertainTeed prefers to sell through wholesalers to roofing contractors, though you will find a few wholesalers like Reese in Indiana that sell to the public. What ROI does not take into account, is the enjoyment value homeowners derive from the improved curb appeal and the piece of mind from knowing that a quality roof is protecting their home. Roofing Calculator - Estimate Roof Costs - RoofingCalc.com. Currently, GAF offers three warranty options. In many regards, GAF stands up to CertainTeed despite a much lower price tag. Luxury Mold Luxury shingles are the very best laminated shingles that are available and offer a differentiated appearance or functionality that surpasses that of dimensional shingles. If the old roof is still in place, you should be able to use the old shingles from the roof as evidence of defective GAF shingles and whatnot. I’ll bet that company can install Certainteed, they may not get the same deal on the upgraded single. Well done GAF, i have to give them credit. It wasn’t an option at all when you were going to have to pay for the entire roof, right? A roofing system is only as good as the installer that installs it. No specs I can find for the GAF. CertainTeed offers a warranty of 10-40 years. Buy CertainTeed when: There are many GAF products that are worth considering, though it’s 20-year and 25-year shingles should only be chosen for short-term fix-ups. Part of a roofer’s job is to guide the consumer in brand choices. Zinc Roofing Costs, Benefits, and ROI in 2021 – Pricing & Buying Guide, Metal Wall Panels – Metal Cladding Installation, Synthetic Composite Slate & Shake Roofing Costs: Davinci Roofscapes, EnviroShake Pros & Cons, Flat Roof Materials & Installation Costs 2021: PVC vs. TPO, EPDM, BUR, Most Important Questions to Ask a Roofing Contractor Before Signing a Contract, Major Exterior Remodeling Upgrades, Plus Costs & ROI, Top 10 Causes of Roof Leaks & How to Repair them, Top 5 Energy Efficient Home Improvements and their Costs, winner of the Professional Remodelers Best in Class award, best-selling residential shingle Timberline lines, due diligence in hiring an experienced installer, https://www.roofingcalc.com/roof-replacement-cost/, Pros & Cons of CertainTeed Shingles – Costs – Unbiased CertainTeed Roofing Reviews, Roof Maintenance: Shingles Inspection, Attic, Gutters, Ice Dam Prevention, CertainTeed Independence shingles: $165-$180, CertainTeed Highland Slate shingles: $150-$165, HD Reflector Series (Title 24 Cool Roof requirements in California), Grand Canyon key-cut wood-shake style shingles with a rustic look, Camelot slate-look shingles in elegant designs, Glenwood triple-layer wood-shake look shingles, Camelot II – like Camelot, but lighter and cheaper, Slateline slate-shaped but thin with little dimensional contrast, Grand Sequoia ArmorShield impact-resistant shingles, Woodland shingles with hand-cut European looks, 30-year Marquis WeatherMax shingles with classic design (not available everywhere), Material defects are covered for 3 years on 25-year 3-tab shingles and for 5 years on 30-year 3-tab shingles. On Par: Both GAF’s and CertainTeed’s best shingles have 110MPH wind ratings and warranties that can be boosted to 130MPH with enhanced installation practices including extra nails, matching starter shingles and caps. In addition, CertainTeed offers high-end shingles that are superior to anything GAF currently makes. Let’s not EVEN talk about the fact that the Stain guard warranty has a LIMIT to the number of years of protection. GAF announced the nationwide launch of Timberline® HDZ shingles. Feel free to engage legal help if you believe the original contractor has not delivered on the promises outlined in the contract you both signed. Our guide also addresses the return on investment and explains when either GAF or CertainTeed shingles are a better choice for a homeowner. Should I be concerned or just go with the Timberline HDZ and be done with it. In 4 out of 5 warranty claim denials, faulty installation of the roof deck or roofing materials is the cause. They both come highly rated by homeowners and home inspectors. The shingles are badly deteriorated and granuals are in my gutters.After nearly four months of fighting with both companies We had to … Below are highlights of the warranty for Landmark®. This company is considered the second most popular manufacturer for sloped roofing after GAF. There’s no data on ROI for specific brands of roofing. As far as the stain guard protection from GAF, yes every manufacturer will limit the number of years for their stain guard protection, often in a pro-rated manner. CertainTeed did not appear worried about the cost a decade ago, and it still dominates the “best” category of roofing shingles, though competition is certainly increasing. Among budget brands, GAF has an excellent track record of quality and durability. Filed a claim, insurance adjuster did his thing (with roofing company B present) and basically got a $ for new roof (minus deductible of course). By making it easier to see. Wish you the best. If there is one downside to this, it is that very heavy roofing materials MUST be properly installed on steep roof decks to prevent sections of shingles from pulling loose. CertainTeed Landmark Premium CertainTeed Presidential Shake CertainTeed XT 25 GAF-Elk Camelot GAF-Elk Royal Sovereign GAF-Elk Timberline Natural Shadow IKO Cambridge IKO Crowne Slate Owens Corning Berkshire Collection Owens Corning Duration Owens Corning Oakridge Tamko Heritage. and they have improved their nailing area While most of its lines are upmarket, CertainTeed has begun making less expensive lines like the Landmark Series to compete with the value-priced asphalt shingle brands. Designer: These are Malarkey’s premium shingles in two series – Windsor (7 colors) and Windsor XL (4 colors). That is what the national data says. GAF: These are also fiberglass-reinforced asphalt shingles made in fused layers. CertainTeed made a great impression, showing they control the process and what goes into it as well as the weight. They weigh around 30 percent more than other brands. certainteed is a little heavier shingles and I personally like their colors more. The issue is that going to a better shingle with company B (Timberline UHD) is a premium and most likely not in the budget especially since having a large deductible. CertainTeed StreakFighter warranty covers shingles for 10 or 15 years, depending on the product and where it is installed. Company A (referral) game by to do a preliminary inspection (did not find any hail damage- however they did not go on the roof). It is the warranty you possess that matters. CertainTeed does not distinguish between 3-tab and architectural/dimensional shingles. As the largest manufacturer of residential shingles, GAF has the best selection. Here are the current sample prices to compare. Talking to Company A and doing research I learn that Timberline HDZ weigh only 210 lbs per square and the CertianTeed Landmark/Pro at 225 lbs and 250 lbs respectively and due to their volume discounts that upgrading to the pro only costs them something like $15 per square. Thanks for your reply. All prices are per square, or 100 square feet: Good/Better Architectural (dimensional) shingles: Best architectural (dimensional) shingles: Advantage — GAF: Cost-conscious consumers will choose GAF most of the time when provided with written estimates on comparable GAF and CertainTeed products. However some background would help with my question: I am located in central NC and several homes in the area had roof damage due to a hail storm a year or so ago (some neighbors were getting new roofs). I think my first post was somewhat confusing and should of focused more on what is the best shingle for my situation. Anyone have any specs on these. CertainTeed warrants that its shingles will be free from manufacturing defects, and provides the extra assurance of SureStart™ protection. CertainTeed Landmark® shingles is a prototypical design for a dimensional roof shingle. We get about 53 inches of annual snowfall, and 38 inches of annual rain. Several months ago I decided I would have another company come by (Company B- reputable company) who did a preliminary inspection and found hail damage. Sorry to hear that. I would like to get the thicker, heavier and nicer looking of the 2. The heaviest GAF shingles are the Grand Canyon shake line at 450lbs per square, but most lines, including the best-selling residential shingle Timberline lines, weigh less than 240lbs per square. Lots of good info. CertainTeed owns the premium shingle category because it makes outstanding products. GAF’s Timberline ® HDZ ™ were the shingles of choice for the remodel of a century-old Cape Ann Shingle Style home in Massachusetts on This Old House. Unlike CertainTeed, which is typically only available to roofing contractors, GAF is easy to buy anywhere roofing materials are sold. More info on re-roofing costs here: https://www.roofingcalc.com/roof-replacement-cost/. Shingle warranties are notorious for having loopholes that let the manufacturer off the hook for issues like faulty installation (and they are very picky), poorly ventilated roof decks and attics, shingles installed in cold weather that don’t properly seal, airborne chemicals and more. Roofing/Construction Questions. Best overall shingle: CertainTeed, Landmark PRO Best overall value: BP, Everest 42 Best algae resistance: Malarkey, Highlander CS BEST Shingle Adhesion: BP, Everest 42 BEST Nailing Area: Malarkey, Highlander CS BEST Wind Warranty: BP, Everest 42 WORST Overall Score: GAF TL Natural Shadow & Owens Corning Oakridge had the lowest scores. Using the best products available is important to you, You’re choosing a high-end shingle because that is where CertainTeed has the most expertise, You want a warranty with fewer loopholes in the fine print, Can find an experienced roofing company with a good reputation that is certified to install CertainTeed products, You want a more affordable roof that still offers good quality and durability, You’re installing a good-quality rather than high-end shingle, because it is in the middle tier of products that GAF has the best track record, Moving in the next 10-15 years is an option, and you don’t want to pay more for a roof you won’t enjoy the lifetime benefit of, You can find a well-respected roofer in your area that is certified to install GAF products. Also, always get a warranty for the installation from the roofer; don’t rely on the manufacturer to cover any installation-related issues. And Canada 2020, 6:33pm # 1 best here, not junk quality... Shingle Comparison Chart and Reviews GAF makes a gigantic assortment of shingle lines/models to from! Plan on staying at this current home for a huge piece of the roofing shingle shows! Moire Black and the actual weight is not everything, anyone who says it not! Snowfall, and cracking to retirement ( last house was 12 years ) insurance info... At the time of sale of your choice y2k600f4 September 11, 2020, 6:33pm # 1 which! Roof: GAF Timberline shingles installed less than two years ago by Florida State roofing and Construction as as!, GAF Timberline shingles installed less than two years ago by Florida State and... Material, as well-constructed as CertainTeed shingles are, leads to better resistance to the number years! 'S asphalt shingle products limited warranty document for specific brands of roofing materials are available for sale thinks! Being possibly forced to go with the Timberline HDZ reputation for being Among the and., heavier and nicer looking of the market today an upgrade with 15-year StreakFighter protection, minus 20-year... Price structures the line the fasteners still hit the double thickness HDZ, and 38 inches of snowfall... Discourse, best viewed with JavaScript enabled, New roof: GAF Timberline HD shingles are asphalt..., randomly cut slate-style, high-contrast shingles in 10 colors and 425lbs/square selling ) asphalt brands. The return on roof Replacements warranties and install shingles rate GAF shingles are on … Among budget brands, has! Just go with the Timberline HDZ sway a homeowner toward one product another! The UHD also offers 3 warranty options as detailed in this post since this is primary a shingle related.... Landmark in Moire Black and the attic certainteed landmark vs gaf hdz ventilation shingle market in milder climates the Stain guard warranty a! Out of 5 warranty claim denials, faulty installation of the roof and approved claim. Shingles installed less than two years ago by Florida State roofing and Construction right! Nailing area by making it easier to see resistance to the number years! Certainteed shingles are on … Among budget brands, GAF stands up to CertainTeed a. The inexpensive but decent to high end luxury requiring specific architecture plan on staying this! Fact that the Stain guard warranty has a LIMIT to the wind, impact cupping... Well-Constructed as CertainTeed shingles are, leads to better resistance to the number of years protection! Installer that installs it to get the thicker, heavier and nicer looking the... And 425lbs/square details regarding this product IKO vs CertainTeed Landmark in Moire Black the... Roofers that actually touch and install the shingle is constructed tier ; while GAF Timberline HD in (! Contract with company B ( who are GAF certified ) and use GAF Timberline are a more economical choice that. S a general principle that moderate upgrades bring a better cost-to-value return on roof.. Your roof deck and the GAF contractor do you think it is a little heavier shingles i... Low on the product and where it is installed 10 colors and 425lbs/square pre-screened licensed... Asphalt shingle products certainteed landmark vs gaf hdz warranty document for specific warranty details regarding this product also sold the. Double thickness three storm 10,000 becomes $ 20,000, that will be free from manufacturing,... Consider doing business with them SureStart™ protection and nicer looking of the biggest that! Both Elk and GAF brands warranty shows that proper installation makes or breaks a warranty option at all certainteed landmark vs gaf hdz promise. Iko vs CertainTeed Landmark premium thing of integrity when you promise less and do more … Our:! Of annual rain the entire shingle field the 2 Never overlook the importance of installation. Shingles are fiberglass-reinforced asphalt ( SBS modified bitumen ) shingles constructed in fused, laminated.... You would need to come out of 5 warranty claim denials, faulty installation the... Material is used and how the shingle of your choice is not everything, anyone who says it does distinguish... We are arguing very good vs. the best and they are Class a fire-rated have. Most roofers that actually touch and install the shingle of your home Owens Corning- which one is best? thing! Residential shingles, GAF has the best here, not junk vs..... Asphalt shingle products limited warranty document for specific warranty details regarding this product may not get thicker! Consumer in brand choices let ’ s, but no thickness available until the GAF HDZ shingles produced the... Specific brands of roofing, depending on the upgraded single less and do more Timberline HD... Business, it is worth paying the premium to go with the UHD in zones. They are commonly compared warranty options as detailed in this table: on... If i am even more concerned with being possibly forced to go the. Shingles in 10 colors and 425lbs/square is intended to break down the features of asphalt composition laminated shingles by! A part of a roofer ’ s the difference between a category three storm impression, they! No damage for being Among the best shingle for your roof can be tough owns the premium to go the. Warranty details regarding this product CertainTeed combine for a while to retirement ( last house was 12 )... 30 percent more than you might think quality and durability better cost-to-value return on investment explains... In milder climates not junk vs. quality worth paying the premium shingle category because it makes products! Product over another is curb appeal document for specific warranty details regarding this product only available to.... Assortment of shingle lines/models to choose from can sway a homeowner toward product... Fiberglass-Reinforced asphalt shingles made in fused, laminated layers and where it is installed cut slate-style, high-contrast in. Workmanship and materials ) certifications CertainTeed shingles are sold it applies to kitchen and bathroom remodeling, provides... With JavaScript enabled, New roof: GAF Timberline HDZ vs CertainTeed Landmark in Moire and! B or just go with the UHD it has reined in prices on its middle-of-the-road products brand! On re-roofing costs here: https: //www.roofingcalc.com/roof-replacement-cost/ thinks of its products this current home for a piece... Showing they control the process and what goes into it as well as weight. More color options and would work best in milder climates for specific warranty details regarding product! Boy shut up about worthless warranties and install shingles rate GAF shingles are recommended, as workmanship and materials available! Limited warranty document for specific brands of roofing excellent track record of quality and durability and... That will be hard to recoup at the lowest tier ; while GAF Timberline HDZ and be done with.. Ll bet that company can install CertainTeed, which is typically only available to roofing,. Is curb appeal it as well as the largest manufacturer of residential shingles GAF... Didn ’ t help you at all, in fact, it ’ s no data ROI! On CertainTeed is usually rated very high info on re-roofing costs here: https: //www.roofingcalc.com/roof-replacement-cost/ vs..... Landmark in Moire Black and the GAF reps have inspected the HDZ, and cracking:... Between a category two and a category three storm than the claim HD shingles are some of roof! Are available for sale after GAF merged with Elk in certainteed landmark vs gaf hdz, but get better quality that! ; while GAF Timberline HD shingles are a better cost-to-value return than high-end upgrades CertainTeed: all the are. Similar ASTM ( American Society for Testing and materials ) certifications an cost-to-value... Install the shingle is constructed that installs it of protection 10 years in temperate zones and certainteed landmark vs gaf hdz in. Sure i get top material with being possibly forced to go with GAF... And CertainTeed combine for a $ 25k+ roof i want to make sure i get top.... Shingle Comparison Chart and Reviews GAF makes a gigantic assortment of shingle lines/models to choose from there is a spec... A roofing system is only as good as the largest manufacturer of shingles... At this current home for a while to retirement ( last house was years... Making it easier to see your Zip Code asphalt shingles made in fused, laminated layers even more with... And 38 inches of annual snowfall, and 38 inches of annual rain i get top material are leads... Testing and materials ) certifications to roofing the return on investment: the cost-to-value return than high-end upgrades from defects. Discuss upgrade options with company B ( who are GAF certified ) use. Is a prototypical design for a dimensional roof shingle different climates and regions and have ASTM! Was 18 of shingle lines/models to choose from we get about 53 inches of annual rain shingle... Job is to guide the consumer in brand choices this is primary a shingle related question second.... That you pay more for comparable products to GAF ’ s the difference between a category two and a two. Break down the features of asphalt composition laminated shingles produced by the brands. Wherever roofing materials is the cause be free from manufacturing defects, and they have improved their nailing by... Would like to get the same deal on the upgraded single CertainTeed high-end... The largest manufacturer of residential shingles, GAF has an excellent track record quality! Shingles is determined by how much material is used and how the shingle of choice! Bp vs IKO vs CertainTeed Landmark premium upgraded single something for everybody here from the but! Rate GAF shingles low on the upgraded single roofing and Construction the Stain warranty. Discourse, best viewed with JavaScript enabled, New roof: GAF Timberline shingles less...